Integrations: Love ‘Em Or Leave ‘Em? 

When it comes to church management software (ChMS), one of the key decisions every church must make is how to handle integrations. Some ChMS platforms offer an all-in-one approach, providing a comprehensive suite of tools within a single ecosystem. Others rely heavily on integrations, allowing churches to connect multiple third-party applications to fill gaps in functionality. Both approaches have their merits, but understanding the cost-benefit of integrations is essential to making an informed decision that aligns with your church’s needs and budget. 

The Allure Of Integrations 

Integrations can be a powerful way to extend the capabilities of a ChMS. They allow churches to leverage best-in-class tools for specific functions such as email marketing, online giving, volunteer scheduling, or children’s check-in. Some advantages of integrations include: 

• Enhanced Functionality: Integrations enable churches to tailor their tech stack to meet their unique needs. 

• Flexibility: If a church finds a new or better tool for a specific task, they can swap out an integration without overhauling their entire ChMS. 

• Best-In-Class Solutions: Rather than relying on one provider for everything, churches can select top-tier applications for specialized tasks. 

However, with all the benefits, integrations come at a cost—both in dollars and in complexity. 

The Hidden Costs Of Integrations 

While integrations provide customization and flexibility, they also introduce challenges that churches must consider: 

• Added Expense: Many integrations come with their own subscription fees, which can quickly add up. 

• Increased Complexity: More integrations mean more systems to manage, troubleshoot, and train staff on. 

• Data Inconsistencies: When multiple platforms are stitched together, data synchronization can become a challenge, leading to inaccurate reports and administrative headaches. 

• Technical Dependencies: Some integrations require ongoing support and maintenance, which can be taxing for smaller church teams without dedicated IT staff. 
  
  

Non-Negotiable Integrations 

While some integrations may be optional, there are certain tools that many churches simply can’t do without, including: 

• Background Checks: Protecting the safety of children and vulnerable individuals is a top priority, making background check integrations essential. 

• Texting Platforms: Communication is key in ministry, and texting remains one of the most effective ways to reach church members quickly. 

• Presentation Software: Sermon slides and streaming are commonplace in the modern church and aren’t included in most ChMS platforms. They elevate the look and feel of your service so this may be a standalone cost. 

While these may not be true integrations and the data is siloed, they often justify their cost due to the mission-critical role they play in church operations. 

Evaluating the Value Of Each Integration 

Church leaders should take time to conduct a cost-benefit analysis of their integrations. Here are some key questions to ask: 

1. Is this integration essential to our ministry, or is it a convenience?
   
   
2. What problem does the integration solve, and is there another way to address it within our ChMS?
   
   
3. How much does the integration cost, and is the return on investment (ROI) worth it? 
   
   
4. How well does this integration work with our current system? Is the data bi-directional or do multiple programs have to be opened to evaluate the information?
   
   
5. Are there redundancies—are we paying for two tools that serve the same purpose?
   
   
6. Does our team have the capacity to manage the technical demands of multiple integrations?
   
   

Time for a ChMS Evaluation? 

If your church relies on a high number of integrations to get basic functionality, it may be time to evaluate whether your current ChMS is still the best fit. Many ChMS providers offer free demos, giving churches the opportunity to explore whether a more comprehensive system could reduce complexity and cost. Sometimes, consolidating tools into an all-in-one platform can lead to significant efficiency gains and savings.

Conclusion 

Integrations can elevate ministry, but each one comes at a cost. Church leaders should be intentional about which tools they integrate into their ChMS, ensuring that each one adds clear value. A strategic approach to integrations—combined with periodic ChMS evaluations—can help churches streamline operations, reduce expenses, and focus on what truly matters: ministry. 

Experts suggest churches should evaluate their software every 2-3 years, even just for due diligence. If it’s been a while since your church last evaluated its ChMS, now may be a great time to explore new options. Whether you stick with your current platform or make a change, the goal is to ensure your technology supports your mission effectively and efficiently. 

Want to see if your staff is aligned? Take this free assessment and share with your staff!